Growing your ecommerce business brings both excitement and complexity. As your brand expands, you'll likely find yourself weighing the benefits of upgrading your technology stack to support increasing sales, customer demands, and operational needs.

For mid-sized brands on Shopify, a critical decision point often emerges: Is it time to upgrade to Shopify Plus? While both platforms share the same core foundation, the differences between Shopify Plus vs Shopify can significantly impact your business's ability to scale efficiently.

At PA Digital Growth, we've guided numerous mid-sized brands through this transition, and we understand the nuances that make this decision crucial to your growth strategy. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore the key differences between Shopify and Shopify Plus, focusing specifically on what matters most to mid-sized businesses poised for expansion.

Understanding the core differences between Shopify plus vs Shopify 

Shopify vs Shopify Plus share the same foundational platform, but Shopify Plus offers enhanced capabilities designed for high-volume merchants and growing brands. Before diving into specific features, let's clarify who each platform is built for:

Target Audience

Shopify Standard is designed for small to medium-sized businesses with straightforward ecommerce needs. It's perfect for brands processing up to $80,000 in monthly sales.

Shopify Plus caters to high-growth mid-market brands and enterprise-level businesses that require advanced features, customization, and support to manage complex operations and higher sales volumes.

Scalability: Supporting Your Growth

For mid-sized brands experiencing rapid growth, scalability becomes a priority concern. Standard Shopify can handle significant traffic, but Shopify Plus offers enterprise-grade infrastructure with several key advantages:

• Unlimited bandwidth and higher processing capacity: Shopify Plus can handle 10,000+ orders per minute versus the more limited capacity of standard Shopify plans.
• Higher API call limits: This is crucial when integrating multiple third-party applications that need to communicate with your store.
• Multi-store management: Operate up to 10 store instances under one account, perfect for brands expanding internationally or managing multiple brands.
• Increased spg eed and performance: Shopify Plus stores benefit from enhanced server resources, resulting in faster load times even during high-traffic events.

According to Shopify's own documentation, brands typically consider upgrading to Plus when their online sales reach around $80,000 per month or when they need the advanced customization and automation features to support operational complexity.

Pricing: Understanding the Investment

One of the most significant differences between the platforms is the pricing structure:

Shopify Standard Plans:

• Basic Shopify: $39/month
• Shopify: $105/month
• Advanced Shopify: $399/month

These plans also include transaction fees (if not using Shopify Payments) ranging from 0.5% to 2% depending on the plan.

Shopify Plus:

• Starts at $2,000/month or 0.25% of monthly revenue (whichever is higher)
• Cap typically around $40,000/month
• No additional transaction fees when using Shopify Payments

While the price difference appears substantial, the ROI calculation isn't straightforward. For many mid-sized businesses, the automation capabilities alone can offset the additional cost through operational efficiencies and reduced manual work.

Advanced Capabilities Critical for Mid-Sized Brands

Automation with Shopify Flow

Shopify Plus includes Shopify Flow, an automation tool that can transform your operations. This tool allows you to create custom workflows that automatically execute based on triggers you define.

Examples of automation that benefit mid-sized brands:

• Automatically tag high-value customers for special treatment
• Create customer service tickets when certain order conditions are met
• Flag potentially fraudulent orders for review
• Reorder inventory when stock levels reach a defined threshold

For growing businesses, these automations create significant time savings and operational efficiency. One mid-sized apparel brand reported saving 30+ hours weekly after implementing Flow automations for customer segmentation and inventory management.

B2B Commerce Capabilities

If your mid-sized brand sells to both consumers and businesses, Shopify Plus offers significant advantages through its B2B functionality:

• Company accounts: Create specific business customer accounts with unique payment terms, custom pricing, and approval workflows
• Custom price lists: Set different pricing for different customer segments
• Volume discounts: Automate tiered wholesale pricing
• Company-specific catalogs: Show different products to different business customers

These B2B capabilities can open substantial revenue opportunities for mid-sized brands looking to expand beyond direct-to-consumer sales.

Checkout Customization

Standard Shopify offers limited checkout customization options, which can impact conversion rates. Shopify Plus merchants gain access to Checkout Extensions and the ability to customize the checkout experience, including:

• Adding custom fields to collect specific information
• Implementing specialized validation rules
• Creating unique upsell opportunities
• Optimizing the checkout flow for specific customer segments

For mid-sized brands focused on conversion rate optimization, this flexibility is invaluable.

Support and Launch Resources

The level of support represents another significant difference between the platforms:

Shopify Support:

• 24/7 email, live chat, and phone support
• Standard response times

Shopify Plus Support:

• Dedicated Launch Manager during onboarding
• Assigned Success Manager for ongoing support
• Priority support queue
• Access to the Plus merchant success programs
• Technical specialists for complex implementations

For mid-sized brands with limited technical resources, this enhanced support can be crucial during critical sales periods, new feature implementations, or troubleshooting complex issues.

Making the Right Decision: Is Shopify Plus Worth It?

To determine if upgrading to Shopify Plus makes sense for your mid-sized brand, consider these key factors:

Signs You're Ready for Shopify Plus

1. Your monthly revenue exceeds $80,000: At this point, the advanced features often pay for themselves.
2. You need workflow automation: If your team spends significant time on repetitive tasks that could be automated.
3. You require advanced customizations: When standard Shopify limitations are constraining your growth.
4. You're expanding internationally: Multi-store management becomes essential for global operations.
5. You're developing B2B channels: The dedicated B2B functionality can transform your wholesale operations.
6. You experience high-volume sales periods: Flash sales or holiday rushes that push the limits of your current infrastructure.

ROI Calculation Framework

When calculating the potential ROI of upgrading to Shopify Plus, consider:

1. Labor savings from automation: Quantify the hours saved through automations and multiply by your labor cost.
2. Increased conversion rate: Even a modest improvement in checkout conversion from customization can significantly impact revenue.
3. New revenue channels: The value of expansion into B2B or international markets.
4. Reduced app costs: Some functionality that requires paid apps in standard Shopify is included in Plus.
5. Value of priority support: The cost savings of faster resolution during critical issues.

For a mid-sized apparel brand processing $150,000 monthly, the upgrade to Shopify Plus solutions typically pays for itself through time savings, increased conversion rates, and expanded sales channels. Our clients often see ROI within the first 3-6 months after implementation of advanced features and optimizations.

Real-World Example: Mid-Sized Brand Transformation

A mid-sized beauty brand with $1.2 million in annual revenue was struggling with manual processes for customer segmentation, inventory management, and order processing. After upgrading to Shopify Plus and implementing strategic automations:

• Customer service time decreased by 30% through automated tagging and segmentation
• Order processing efficiency improved by 25%
• Checkout conversion rate increased by 1.2% through customization
• B2B sales grew from 15% to 28% of total revenue within 8 months
• International expansion to two new markets was completed in half the originally estimated time

The result was an incremental $450,000 in annual revenue against an increased platform cost of approximately $20,000, delivering a substantial return on investment.

Platform Selection Is a Strategic Decision

Choosing between Shopify and Shopify Plus is ultimately about aligning your ecommerce technology with your business growth strategy. For mid-sized brands with aggressive growth goals, complex operations, or expansion plans, Shopify Plus provides capabilities that can remove technical barriers and accelerate growth.

However, brands still in earlier growth phases may find the standard Shopify plans sufficient until they reach the technical limitations or complexity that necessitate an upgrade.

The optimal approach is often to start with a standard Shopify plan and upgrade to Plus when your business reaches the inflection point where the advanced features directly support your strategic objectives and deliver clear ROI.

Ready to evaluate if Shopify Plus is right for your mid-sized brand? Our team at PA Digital Growth specializes in helping businesses make this transition seamlessly, implementing the automations and optimizations that maximize your return on investment. Contact us today for a personalized assessment of your ecommerce growth potential.

Frequently Asked Questions